Flights from New York to Central America & Caribbean
21 routes from LGA · cheapest from $93

Other regions from New York:

Central America & Caribbean Routes from New York

Sorted by estimated price. Set a price alert on any route to get texted when fares drop.

LGANAS
Nassau
Bahamas
Est. $93
round trip
~3h flightTrack price →
LGAGCM
Grand Cayman
Cayman Islands
Est. $130
round trip
~4h flightTrack price →
LGAMBJ
Montego Bay
Jamaica
Est. $131
round trip
~4h flightTrack price →
LGACUN
Cancun
Mexico
Est. $132
round trip
~4h flightTrack price →
LGAPUJ
Punta Cana
Dominican Republic
Est. $132
round trip
~4h flightTrack price →
LGASDQ
Santo Domingo
Dominican Republic
Est. $132
round trip
~4h flightTrack price →
LGAKIN
Kingston
Jamaica
Est. $134
round trip
~4h flightTrack price →
LGASJU
San Juan
Puerto Rico
Est. $136
round trip
~4h flightTrack price →
LGASTT
St. Thomas
US Virgin Islands
Est. $138
round trip
~4h flightTrack price →
LGASXM
St. Maarten
Sint Maarten
Est. $143
round trip
~4h flightTrack price →
LGAANU
Antigua
Antigua and Barbuda
Est. $150
round trip
~5h flightTrack price →
LGAMTY
Monterrey
Mexico
Est. $153
round trip
~5h flightTrack price →
LGAAUA
Aruba
Aruba
Est. $165
round trip
~5h flightTrack price →
LGACUR
Curacao
Curacao
Est. $168
round trip
~5h flightTrack price →
LGAUVF
St. Lucia
Saint Lucia
Est. $170
round trip
~5h flightTrack price →
LGAMEX
Mexico City
Mexico
Est. $176
round trip
~5h flightTrack price →
LGABGI
Barbados
Barbados
Est. $177
round trip
~5h flightTrack price →
LGAGDL
Guadalajara
Mexico
Est. $187
round trip
~5h flightTrack price →
LGAPOS
Trinidad
Trinidad and Tobago
Est. $187
round trip
~5h flightTrack price →
LGAPVR
Puerto Vallarta
Mexico
Est. $194
round trip
~6h flightTrack price →
LGASJD
Los Cabos
Mexico
Est. $202
round trip
~6h flightTrack price →

About Central America & Caribbean

The Caribbean and Central America are the closest international destinations to the US, offering tropical beaches, Mayan ruins, and vibrant cultures. Many islands have direct 2-4 hour flights from major US cities, making them perfect for long weekends.

Visa Requirements

Most Caribbean islands and Central American countries allow US citizens visa-free entry for tourism. Mexico allows 180 days, most others allow 30-90 days. Always carry your passport, as some islands have strict entry requirements.

Best Time to Visit

Peak season is December-April (dry season, expensive). Hurricane season is June-November (cheapest, but risky August-October). Shoulder seasons (May, November) offer the best balance. Summer can be hot and humid but prices drop significantly.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much are flights from New York to Central America & Caribbean?

Flights from New York to Central America & Caribbean typically start around $93 round trip. The cheapest destination is currently Nassau (Bahamas). Prices vary widely by season and booking timing.

When is the best time to fly from New York to Central America & Caribbean?

Peak season is December-April (dry season, expensive). Hurricane season is June-November (cheapest, but risky August-October). Shoulder seasons (May, November) offer the best balance. Summer can be hot and humid but prices drop significantly.

Which Central America & Caribbean destination is easiest to reach from New York?

Nassau is one of the closest Central America & Caribbean destinations from New York, with a flight time of approximately 3 hours.

Track Central America & Caribbean fares from New York

Set your target price and we'll text you the moment fares from New York to Central America & Caribbean drop. Free to start.

Set a Price Alert — Free
Free — no credit card needed

Get flight deals nobody else sees

Error fares. Flash sales. $300+ savings on routes you actually want. We scan thousands of routes daily — you hear about it first.

✈ Error fares & flash sales📉 SMS price drop alerts📬 Weekly deals from your airport

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. Want instant SMS alerts? →

Payments securely processed via Stripe.com